← Setups

Tandem helicopter general questions translated

Public Talk › Setups · Started by Master FBL on 27 July 2026 01:1827.07.2026 01:18
Master FBL 27 July 2026 01:1827.07.2026 01:18
Moinsen
Since I've been interested in the tandem story for several years, I have some perhaps "stupid" questions.
Could one operate each swashplate on a tandem aircraft with different servos, e.g., the front swashplate with a GDW 992 and the rear one with a KST 2208, both 8.4 servos?
What would happen if the diameter at the front of the head was perhaps 2 cm smaller (hypothetical question)?
I understand that something needs to be mixed in for Nick Heck, but could this be reversed using a macrocell with negative pitch to enable inverted flight?
And is it really necessary for both rotor heads to be mounted on extremely soft bearings? What would happen with POM damping?

Best regards
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 27 July 2026 09:1127.07.2026 09:11
Good morning,

It's all just theory, but it should be possible to fly different servo sets as long as both are suitable.

The different rotor diameters shouldn't pose a significant problem initially; this should be compensated for within a certain range by adjusting the mixing ratios. However, this doesn't change the fact that, physically, in this example, there's less 'oomph' at the front than at the rear, and the rotor with the lower 'oomph' represents the limit of what's possible in the roll-pitch-yaw axis mix (and pitch...).

The mixture is designed to also take the pitch zero crossing into account. I know at least one pilot who flies aerobatics (loops) with a Chinook, and another who flies his Flettner like there's no tomorrow.

The rotor heads do not need to be mounted 'extremely softly', but they should have significant damping, otherwise harmful resonances will quickly occur in the model.

One macrocell, 'good luck with that' :-) ... we're talking more about ' all macrocells ', which can be set relatively easily/clearly via the Pro app.

Nevertheless, or perhaps precisely because of this, it's essential to thoroughly familiarize yourself with VBar and helicopters. And before conducting any experiments related to the question, let's be clear: these things simply work and fly quite... let's say, uniquely... aerobatics are something you can consider, but only later. And then there are certainly the mechanical stresses and the aerodynamic limits, which are significantly narrower. Unexpected reactions are to be expected; you practically have to be prepared to crash the thing if something doesn't develop as expected.

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Master FBL 27 July 2026 10:1027.07.2026 10:10
Hi Eddi,

Thank you for the information. Very helpful.
Of course, aerobatics always involves risks.
Attached is a video of him doing an inverted flight in a tandem paraglider. 16 years ago.

https://youtu.be/uErdPaFVHaU?is=fDS1a_J_-fHYTSyS

Best regards.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 27 July 2026 12:2627.07.2026 12:26
Wow... that transition onto his back was quite something... :-) ... he probably didn't know what was going to happen either ^^

Possibly even with an inverted flight switch ^^ (which is probably what you mean, reversing the mix...).

Unless Rainer writes something completely contrary, I wouldn't have any qualms about, for example, putting such a box in a loop at the height of your back and supporting it, to see how it plays, so that you have a way out, a plan B.

But first, we need to get it flying ;-) including the special features that have already been requested.

Please pay particular attention to all the explanations provided; I'll copy one of them here:

Quote: vstabi.info
Since we are not familiar with the specific helicopter in question, it is the user's responsibility to find sensible ways to adjust the control parameters, etc. Our macro cells offer maximum flexibility in this regard. Please test any changes to the settings in a dry run before each flight; the pilot is solely responsible for their model and its safety!

This applies particularly when other apps are used that also utilize the macro cells. Simultaneous use with the Nitro Special Gas Curve App or the Touchbutton App is therefore prohibited.

Why? Apps that also feed macrocells in the background might overwrite tandem cells, and then strange things can happen.

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Master FBL 27 July 2026 20:5527.07.2026 20:55
Yes, the half-roll or whatever he was doing looked quite adventurous :-)

Regarding the apps running in the background... I only bought the Tandem app, loaded the Tandem settings, and ran it on a Neo.
To see how the servos move.

I have never dealt with macrocells before, or tried to do anything with them.
I don't think I have any macrocells running anywhere else?

No, I didn't mean a reverse flight switch. I thought something like that could be solved electronically with macrocells.

Best regards, Janis



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 07/27/2026 08:56PM by Master FBL.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 28 July 2026 09:2628.07.2026 09:26
Good morning,

Yesterday I spoke to a pilot who also flies aerobatics (loops) with a Chinook.

Many years ago, he crashed the helicopter three times because the helicopter – back then not equipped with the NEO/EVO tandem app and VBar Control, but just sort of with a GY 401 on the tail – started pirouettes upside down from a loop, and he couldn't get out of it. It's a different kind of aerodynamics, and I think if the helicopter falls through its own downwash with its rotors fully articulated, it ends up much like Top Gun.

He now flies with VBar/VBar Control, but sticks to speed loops, which he doesn't always perform... he's not flying a 'toy' though ^^
More like this .

So... caution is still advised.

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Master FBL 28 July 2026 20:1128.07.2026 20:11
Oh dear,
He doesn't exactly fly that giant thing gently either :-)

Thanks for your help :-)
machine-translated from German · Show original
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless