← Logo 200

Logo 200 oscilations

Mikado Model Helicopters › Logo 200 · Started by morph on 8 June 2025 07:4208.06.2025 07:42
morph 8 June 2025 07:4208.06.2025 07:42
Hi guys, i need some advice how to tackle vibrations in my poor logo 200.

First, Tail
OK, everyone knows logo 200 tail. Is working until is not. But, for ex, i have it in bank 3 @ 5800rpms, when is hovering and no wind is ok, no slow wobble. In the same scenario, in inverted, just hovering inverted, the tail wobbles left to right slow, with big amplitude, like 3cm to right, 3 to left. What can i check or at least what can i try in my touch control radio? What settings? If i go up with wag suppress is worst. In the scenario where wind is more than 2-3m/s, it wobbles in any position. I am not a 3d flyier, but still i lose tail in easy figures. I tried tail gain between 80-100, 80 was helping to slow wobble, not to solve it, but seems that the tail blows more easly. (doh)
I have tried also optimisation flight, same results.


Second problem, when i do some vertical tik-toks, the heli wobbles when i change the pitch from negative to positive, so i dont know if is clear, but in tik tok figure, when heli needs to go in the other way, it wobbles from cyclic and this kind of behaivour i saw it also on my 420DD and 700Raw. (on 700 the problem kind of got away after some optimisations flights, on my 420 it is still a slight problem, but manageable from sticks.)

So, i would like to know where to start or what to do. The 200 seems so loose, even a inexperienced flyer can see it. I tried also some cyclic gain, from 9 default up to 20, this heli feels everywhere, without any precision.

Thank you for any input.



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 06/08/2025 07:45AM by morph.
morph 10 June 2025 20:3810.06.2025 20:38
So, no one?
Ok, lets take just the tail

default settings, inverted just hovering inverted, tail has some 3-4cm slow oscillation random, without wind
I have tried to lower P on tail, acceleration, gain but still not ok

If I do left-right movement from rudder stick, on the left (nose go to left) tail stops with quick oscillation, like to much gain. If I lower gain until 45 (from 100) left is ok, but nose to right the tail oscilate slow 3-4 cm. Even if I go up with gain again, nose right stil loose.
With gain 100, as default setting, tail motor get hot in hover and little left-right maneuvers. I have lowered P gain from 110 to 100, same. I have lowered acceleration from 35 to 25, less wobble, but same behavior.

any Ideas? ty



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 06/10/2025 08:47PM by morph.
morph 10 June 2025 22:2110.06.2025 22:21
I have found an yt that is doing exactly as mine

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bDP_tYxAok

Also in tiktok, i have the same behavior. Wobbling on stops.
morph 13 June 2025 09:2013.06.2025 09:20
I still insist:

My settings now

Tailrotor
Expo 50 / 40 / 40
Yaw Rate 90 / 110 / 124 (too much yaw?)
Tail Gain 80 / 90 / 90 (100 default, at 60 is not overshoot when stop after a max 360 nose to left, basically (anti clockwise-ccw)

Proportional 90 / 100 / 100 (default 110, nothing changed in behaviour)
Integral 70 / 75 / 80
I Limiter -1 / -1 / -1
I Discharge -1 / -1 / -1
Differential 100 / 100 / 100
Coll. Precomp. 50 / 50 / 50
Cycl. Precomp. 20 / 20 / 20
Stop Gain A. 0 / 0 / 0
Stop Gain B. 100 / 100 / 100
Optimizer A 10 / 10 / 10
Optimizer B 34 / 34 / 34
Wag Suppression 0 / 0 / 0
Tail Acceleration 32 (35 default, nothing changed)

Still, when inverted, random slow wobble left to right. This is why i reduced tail acc. I will try to take a video in the weekend. Also ccw hard stops, tail bounce with high frequency. In cw, tail bounce once, slower but bigger amplitude. But without tally, seems to be normal.

I will try to modify stop gain B, but i don't know all setting what they do.


What chatGPT recommends for this settings and behaviour

| Setare | Valoare nou? propus? |
| ----------------- | ------------------------------------------- |
| Proportional | 85 |
| Stop Gain B | 70 (po?i coborî la 60 dac? mai face bounce) |
| Optimizer B | 25-30 |
| Tail Acceleration | 30-32 |

I will not translate, you can figure the settings.

I write this down to be like a short log of trail testing. Maybe it will help others too.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06/13/2025 09:22AM by morph.
Eddi E. aus G. 13 June 2025 10:0613.06.2025 10:06
Hi,

ChatGPT, really? :-)
Please don't forget to provide feedback to it, too, if it's suggestions worked for you, or not :-)

My two cents (old school home grown intelligence, disputable ^^), before trying and messing: do a new setup, do a trim flight, then try again.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
morph 13 June 2025 10:1813.06.2025 10:18
Desperate times desperate measures. Some times is ok to listen to the imaginary friend :-)

I did unbind the model, binded again, but no default settings, I will try a new setup. I have change also the linkage, servo-swash, the lenght of them as how it came from factory were way off, visible with naked eye that none were the same. I did a trim flight when i changed the links.
Tomorrow i will reach the flying field, if the wind will let me do a trim flight i will do the new setup, but first i will try the AI settings (for sure will be a crap).
Eddi E. aus G. 13 June 2025 12:0513.06.2025 12:05
Hi,

keep us updated, I'm curious, of course.
Imaginary friend, that's good!

Binding anew usually makes no difference.
It's just the way transmitter and receiver exchange numbers, so they can communicate.
At each power on, current center positions etc. are updated, not like other systems where they were stored permanently e.g. for fail safe or such.

New Setup, on the other hand, fixed quite a lot of issues already, and instantly :-)
. do
. trim (visual accuracy is good enough, swash plate level? blade tips touch when folded?)
. trim flight (maybe there's a way to do it indoors, an empty garage or such is usually sufficient, if you feel confident enough).

Particularly with LOGO 200, the window in which parameters work satisfactorily (for a requested head speed) is pretty narrow.
Your imaginary friend might be lucky, but I wouldn't rely on it ... be careful, and be prepared to land instantly, fly where dropping it eventually (motor off) is not automatically causing damage.

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
morph 13 June 2025 19:1013.06.2025 19:10
I have tried, all settings, nothing happens, is the same like no effect.

Only when I move down tail gain to 60 there is no overshoot and sound ok.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/NTbCygZQyEg before new setup, all settings almost default.
It can be seen that cw, so no thrust in tail, I have one big oscillation, like 3 cm, ccw you can hear the oscilations.
Probably was better to disable lightness for the movie. Anyway, there was no wind, so tail was almost ok.


I did a new setup, setting 0 pitch, then a trim flight (I saved the bad config). Did some pirouettes to check the status and all ok.
Still the same, same behavior.
I have change the tail blade again, with an omp v2 one, still the same. I will see more tomorrow at the field, narrow space for doing something at home. Maybe I can catch all the "problems" on tape.

I have had with heli 3 crashes, one that damaged a servo and 2 with no harm, not even shaft bend in tall grass (posted on my yt). But I remember that the heli did the same from the beginning. If I compare with an omp m2 evo at field, mine is the worst swinging all over. I am not a very good flyer, but on yt, the little one is almost perfect.
morph 14 June 2025 10:3014.06.2025 10:30
Unfortunately, is almost unflyable. Tail is almost everywhere

https://youtube.com/shorts/65eApJ9WkK4?si=F_7CGGkssF3Gnpdk
morph 14 June 2025 17:2214.06.2025 17:22
Less wind different settings, heli flew like a champ.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/h02fVNCkNQk


I have tried an omp m2 evo, tail the same, but no slow wobble ever. (per total, is flys so bad in comparation with logo)
morph 14 June 2025 21:5014.06.2025 21:50
So, I have some time now.

What I have changed:
bank 3 5500rpm Dont think it means something
Tail acceleration 32, again don't think it has big influence
Optimizer B 15
Optimizer A 5
That's it, no gain change, no proportional, no gain stop nothing else changed.
What is strange, is that bank 2 is more ok on windy day than bank 3.

Anyway, something is fishy, I would like to fly this helicopter more than others.

What I have now, on low wind day, 2-8km/h heli flies very nice, not wobble in hover no strange tail moves. If the wind is above 10Km/h it starts to wobble even in hover and bigger possibility to blow the tail. Today 3 time tail blowed.

Have a great weekend who reads this lines.

cheers.
Eddi E. aus G. 16 June 2025 09:1816.06.2025 09:18
Hi,

thank you for the extensive documentation.

The tail blowing is unfortunately an effect which can not really be improved, with NEO and V7.
You 'just' need to keep a constant load on the tail (difficult enough, it really seems to be an intermediate problem, beginners don't often do such maneuvers, they fly forward :-) , and experienced pilots have the experience to anticipate—and even then, they get it occasionally, but they just act as if it was part of their routine :-) ).
High winds don't help, either, because you adapt your collective management—naturally—unload the disc where you wouldn't in less windy conditions.

V8 with EVO micro should bring a real improvement here, but that's still a bit in the future.

The wagging is a bit strange, though, but right now I have no idea where to tweak :-/

What vibration levels show?
Since you had some mishaps, one thing you might want to check is, is there any axial play or binding, in the main shaft (between where it's bolted into the motor, and the clamp ring)?
Maybe still worth checking the shafts and bearings (again). For the main shaft, run it without rotor head, feel the shaft e.g. with a finger nail: should run smoothly. For the feathering shaft, hold by the blade holders between thumb and index finger, apply some (not much!) bending force outside-down-inside, up. If the hub in between rotates noticeably, it's possibly because of a bent feathering shaft. Or, remove just one blade, put any allen wrench into the blade holder bolt there, rotate: if the blade on the other side winks, same. Not easy to manage, on a micro, though, to rotate the bolt independently.

—Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
morph 16 June 2025 11:2216.06.2025 11:22
I will check again shafts and bearings, but i started this topic after i changed that piece with bearing in it, that sits between servos and hold mainshaft (due to bearing) some coaxiality mount, main shaft, servo linkage, blades and tail blades. Feathering shaft seemed ok at that time. This was Sunday in the morning. And after tests, i came exhausted on the forum for new ideas, thinking was a software problem. But this slow tail wag is was present from the beginning, i mean when i bought the heli from what i remember.

I will attached log from that day (very clean after rework), with no problems and logs from saturday, 14.06. (a lot of vibration)

The heli had same behaviour, actually this Saturday (14.06) i could have some goods flights, with no wagging. It is strange, because i can have a good flight and 10 minute after a bad flight, with wagging. The only thing different is pack. I have 2 omp packs, same as the one heli comes in the box, 2 750Mah gen ace 60c (the same weight as omp ones) and one 700mah genace (lighter than omp ones).

I need more tests, but next week i'll be away from the flying field. Attachments:
open | download - VC-11006069_VB-0020053786_FL-1749393646_vbar_after_parts_changed_sunday.zip (1.5 KB)
morph 16 June 2025 11:3016.06.2025 11:30
Another log, i think that one from 8.06 is not relevant, too short. I was testing that day with limited space.

Anyway, thank you for implication. ;-)



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06/16/2025 11:44AM by morph. Attachments:
open | download - VC-11006069_VB-0020053786_FL-1749400692_vbar.zip (888 bytes)
morph 16 June 2025 19:4716.06.2025 19:47
Eddi E. aus G. Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------

> The wagging is a bit strange, though, but right
> now I have no idea where to tweak :-/
>
> What vibration levels show? HIGH
> Since you had some mishaps, one thing you might
> want to check is, is there any axial play or
> binding, in the main shaft (between where it's
> bolted into the motor, and the clamp ring)? NO
> Maybe still worth checking the shafts and bearings
> (again). For the main shaft, run it without rotor
> head, feel the shaft e.g. with a finger nail: Smooth as butter
> should run smoothly. For the feathering shaft,Changed, it was bent
> hold by the blade holders between thumb and index
> finger, apply some (not much!) bending force
> outside-down-inside, up. If the hub in between
> rotates noticeably, it's possibly because of a
> bent feathering shaft. Or, remove just one blade,
> put any allen wrench into the blade holder bolt
> there, rotate: if the blade on the other sideit was winking, I change the feathering shaft
> winks, same. Not easy to manage, on a micro,
> though, to rotate the bolt independently.
>
> —Eddi


Thank Eddi for going trough with me. I did a short test, seems everything good, but is golden hour, no wind no nothing, even a feather will fly good :-) If I have some time tomorrow, I will give it a spin to see what is happening, but for sure that bent feathering shaft was the main issue. Another thing, but I don't know if it an issue is tail motor. It sound strange without blade, some whistling sound



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06/16/2025 07:48PM by morph.
Eddi E. aus G. 17 June 2025 08:5117.06.2025 08:51
Hi again,

fingers crossed that this was it. Goes a bit in the line with, if the main blades are attached too firmly, wobbles can occur.
The rotor head or particularly that small size helicopters can be pretty sensitive :-)

Tail motor, I think but can't be sure, if it's running free, it could over rev, run into some kind of resonance.
But could also be bearings, or something else rubbing.
Really hard to tell, with those tiny beasts.

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
morph 17 June 2025 20:4417.06.2025 20:44
No, doesn't work. it wobble from his hart, everything wobbles. Maybe I don't know how to tic-toc, but this little devil trembles like a boat in the wind.

Tail still wobble in no wind condition, especially in inverted, if I try tic-tocs, heli wobbles on cyclic and tail, tail at every stop from any maneuver it's drifst. if I go from left to right, eleron only, tail wobbles. The sensor is toasted or I got a bad batch, from what I remember, same behavior from the beginning.

So, back to the first post. I will start again after I come back from holiday.
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless