← VPlane / VBasic VLink

Auto trim can be auto trouble

VBar › VPlane / VBasic VLink · Started by AmokTim on 30 August 2015 22:2530.08.2015 22:25
AmokTim 30 August 2015 22:2530.08.2015 22:25
I am, trying vplane on a couple of my planes. I used autotrim on the first and it went fine. On the second it kept adding a lot of trim that made the plane want to sharply climb and roll for some reason I do not yet understand.

I had it happen once and was able to get the plane down safely. I cleared the autotrims and tried again. Same thing, bu this time I let it go for longer and it made it so I had little control over the plane. I had to hold almost full down and left aileron keep it level.

The issue arises that once it adds all that trim, there is not much you can do. I could not take my eyes off the plane long enough to go through the couple of levels of radio menus to clear the auto trim. And all that trim left me little room for actually controlling the airplane. The second time I was not so lucky and broke the plane.

So a question and a suggestion.

The question: are when you turn on auto-trim are you supposed to just let the plane fly and it will determine what it needs to hold itself level, or apply the control inputs while it is on to make if fly level? I tried both and neither did me much good. But knowing will help for next time.

So my suggestion make the function use the three levels switches with states of off, on and clear. Then you can reset the trims with a flick of a switch and not have to search menus on the radio.
Eddi E. aus G. 31 August 2015 08:3631.08.2015 08:36
Hi Tim,

you are supposed to let go of the sticks, as in Auto Trim on the heli. When left alone, the sensor 'listens' to the movements of the model and applies as much trim a needed.

I would be curious: when you flipped the switch, did the plane kind of go out of control (climb and roll) by itself?
I can hardly imagine that Auto Trim would deflect the control surfaces in such a way, only if it had an improper init and the sensor centers were not learned properly, but even then.

A guess: what about the setup: is the VBar mounted the way it's programmed in the wizard? Servos connected to the proper ports?

The three level switch is a good point, though.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
AmokTim 31 August 2015 12:4031.08.2015 12:40
I think it is set up correctly, but I will double check. It is a large tail dragger, so it does not sit level in the initialization. Could this be an issue?

When I let go of the sticks it did act as if the corrections were taking it the wrong way. And based on what you said, when I tried to keep it level and fought its input when autotrim was on, I probably induced large trim numbers. But once they where there, I could do nothing. I could not let it fly hands off to autotrim because it was so far out of trim it would crash in the time needed. And I could not take my eyes off long enough to go through the menus. A "reset the autotrim" function would have been very nice!
ulrich 31 August 2015 14:1031.08.2015 14:10
I think there is something reversed. This is not the normal behaviour. You do not need to reset the trim, if it is set up correctly, it will trim the plan in a few seconds, so a reset does not make any sense.

The behaviour you describe sounds 100% like a reversed setup, so the trim is working in the opposit direction it schould.

It dosent matter how the plane sits on powerup. It just has to rest without motion, exactly the same as on helis.

Additionally take care to use the latest VPlane Version, there was a old version that "forgot" the Trim settings on negative values. Not as critical, but still ugly...

so long ... Uli
http://www.vstabi.de



1 mal bearbeitet. Zuletzt am 31.08.2015 14:11 von ulrich.
AmokTim 8 September 2015 00:4508.09.2015 00:45
I just got around to rebuilding the plane. I checked the orientation and....as prediected I had it wrong! I had wire forward/backward reversed which exlplains a lot.

I still think having a reset on the autotrim would be helpful. It was static trimmed well enough to fly OK. The auto trim make it unflyable. It was caused by a stupid bulder error, but still, the auto trim make it unflyable. On any other radio I could back out the trims (or I would notice my trim was doing opposite what I wanted and that would make me check). Having the ability to quickly go back to the "neutral" state could save other planes.
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless