← VBar NEO/EVO VLink

Question regarding helicopter crash, VBar neo and VLink yge 205hvt translated

VBar › VBar NEO/EVO VLink · Started by Kurvenkratzer on 16 November 2019 19:4616.11.2019 19:46
Kurvenkratzer 16 November 2019 19:4616.11.2019 19:46
I came across my helicopter today.

The only strange thing I could read in the log was...
YGE Setpoint noise

The controller is a YGE 205hvt with keto bec and the VBar neo VLink with VBar gov.

Perhaps someone here can help me....
machine-translated from German · Show original
RV 16 November 2019 22:3116.11.2019 22:31
Dann häng mal bitte das Fluglog und das UI Log hier an zum ansehen.

regards (EN) / Gruss (DE)

Rainer Vetter

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Posting and answering - please use a PC and a standard keyboard. Answer all questions fully, take the needed time, don't forget probably requested attachments.

Für Posts und Antworten bitte einen PC und eine richtige Taststaur benutzen sowie alle Fragen vollständig abarbeiten. Nehmt Euch Zeit, beantwortet Rückfragen in Ruhe und vollständig.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Für Einzelkommunikation bitte ausschließlich Email verwenden! - PN, Messenger, Chat usw. werden nicht bearbeitet.
For single user communication please send a email only! PM, Messenger, Chat etc. won't be read.
Kurvenkratzer 17 November 2019 09:3917.11.2019 09:39
I've copied these two logs from my cloud.
I hope this is correct, I've never used this before...

11/16/2019 1:44:40 p.m.; VBar Start -- KSE 700
16.11.2019 13:44:41 Good; Reset Reason: Power On
16.11.2019 13:44:41 Info; Bank 1 loaded
16.11.2019 13:44:41 Info; Bank 2 loaded
16.11.2019 13:44:41 Good; Engine switch neutral restart
16.11.2019 13:44:44 Info; Calibration complete
11/16/2019 1:44:48 PM Good; YGE ESC detected
16.11.2019 13:47:51 Info; Bank 2 loaded
16.11.2019 13:47:52 Info; Bank 3 loaded
16.11.2019 13:47:54 Info; Bank 1 loaded
16.11.2019 13:48:10 Info; Speed controller switched ON
16.11.2019 13:48:10 Good; Motor switch Motor On
16.11.2019 13:48:12 Info; Bank 2 loaded
11/16/2019 1:48:13 PM Warn;Low RPM: 643 RPM
11/16/2019 1:48:17 PM Info;Increased vibration level
11/16/2019 1:48:26 PM Info;YGE Setpoint Noise
11/16/2019 1:48:27 PM Info;Increased vibration level
16.11.2019 13:48:38 Error; Dangerous vibrations
16.11.2019 13:48:46 Error; Roll sensor is outside the measuring range
11/16/2019 1:48:46 PM Info; Bailout start
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Info; Off - Regulator - Umin: 46.2V Imax: 100.3A Temp: 33
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Info; No signal from the speed sensor
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Info; Speed controller switched to OFF
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Good; Motor switch Motor Off
16.11.2019 13:48:47 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:48 Good; Engine switch neutral restart
16.11.2019 13:48:48 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:48 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
11/16/2019 1:48:48 PM Info;Increased vibration level
16.11.2019 13:48:49 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:49 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:49 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:49 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:49 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:50 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:50 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:50 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:48:50 Info; Bailout End
16.11.2019 13:48:50 Info; Pilot bailout, oversteered
16.11.2019 13:50:22 Info; Bank 1 loaded
16.11.2019 13:50:22 Info; Speed controller switched ON
16.11.2019 13:50:23 Good; Motor switch Motor On
11/16/2019 1:50:25 PM Warn;Low RPM: 18 RPM
16.11.2019 13:50:25 Info; Off - Regulator - Umin: 48.5V Imax: 75.0A Temp: 25
16.11.2019 13:50:25 Info; Speed controller switched to OFF
16.11.2019 13:50:25 Good; Motor switch Motor Off
16.11.2019 13:50:26 Good; Engine switch neutral restart
16.11.2019 13:50:32 Good; Motor switch Motor Off
16.11.2019 13:50:33 Good; Engine switch neutral restart
16.11.2019 13:50:34 Info; Speed controller switched ON
16.11.2019 13:50:34 Good; Motor switch Motor On
16.11.2019 13:50:35 Info; Speed controller switched to OFF
16.11.2019 13:50:35 Info; Off - Regulator - Umin: 49.2V Imax: 0.0A Temp: 26
16.11.2019 13:50:35 Good; Motor switch Motor Off
16.11.2019 13:50:35 Good; Engine switch neutral restart
16.11.2019 13:50:58 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:50:58 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:50:59 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:51:00 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:51:00 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:51:08 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
16.11.2019 13:51:09 Warning; The cyclic ring is active
11/16/2019 1:54:15 p.m.;VBar Logfile End -- 11/16/2019 -- 1:54:14 p.m
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 17 November 2019 09:4117.11.2019 09:41
Und hier der Passende UI Log

16.11.2019 13:48:10;Date;I(A);U(V);(Q)mAh;Headspeed(rpm);PWM(%);Temp(C)
16.11.2019 13:48:10;0.4;50.1;19.0;18;0;19
16.11.2019 13:48:11;0.6;50.1;19.0;18;2;19
16.11.2019 13:48:11;1.3;50.1;29.0;105;5;19
16.11.2019 13:48:12;2.1;50.1;20.0;189;11;19
16.11.2019 13:48:12;3.0;50.0;20.0;323;13;19
16.11.2019 13:48:13;4.7;50.0;20.0;499;19;19
16.11.2019 13:48:13;4.6;50.0;21.0;643;23;19
16.11.2019 13:48:14;5.8;50.0;22.0;776;28;19
16.11.2019 13:48:14;7.3;49.9;23.0;885;31;19
16.11.2019 13:48:15;7.8;49.9;24.0;917;35;20
16.11.2019 13:48:15;9.0;49.8;25.0;1087;39;20
16.11.2019 13:48:16;9.9;49.8;26.0;1119;42;20
16.11.2019 13:48:16;12.1;49.7;28.0;1275;46;20
16.11.2019 13:48:17;13.6;49.6;30.0;1340;50;20
16.11.2019 13:48:17;18.1;49.5;31.0;1471;52;20
16.11.2019 13:48:18;17.5;49.5;34.0;1596;56;20
16.11.2019 13:48:18;18.6;49.4;37.0;1706;60;21
16.11.2019 13:48:19;16.5;49.5;49.0;1766;62;21
16.11.2019 13:48:19;15.9;49.5;41.0;1787;63;21
16.11.2019 13:48:20;41.5;48.8;45.0;1824;70;21
16.11.2019 13:48:20;51.2;48.4;53.0;1797;71;21
16.11.2019 13:48:21;9.4;49.5;55.0;1816;61;22
16.11.2019 13:48:21;16.1;49.3;57.0;1783;64;22
16.11.2019 13:48:22;66.4;48.1;61.0;1773;72;22
16.11.2019 13:48:22;73.9;47.8;69.0;1767;73;22
16.11.2019 13:48:23;23.4;49.0;72.0;1790;66;22
16.11.2019 13:48:23;56.4;48.2;78.0;1767;66;22
16.11.2019 13:48:24;64.6;48.0;72.0;1815;72;23
16.11.2019 13:48:24;41.0;48.4;87.0;1764;66;23
16.11.2019 13:48:25;72.9;47.6;95.0;1785;73;23
16.11.2019 13:48:25;43.7;48.3;101.0;1775;67;23
16.11.2019 13:48:26;75.6;47.5;109.0;1800;73;24
16.11.2019 13:48:26;39.6;48.3;113.0;1794;68;24
16.11.2019 13:48:27;37.4;48.5;120.0;1673;64;24
16.11.2019 13:48:27;37.2;48.2;126.0;1818;70;25
16.11.2019 13:48:28;35.9;48.2;133.0;1776;69;25
16.11.2019 13:48:28;9.0;48.8;144.0;1833;63;25
16.11.2019 13:48:29;73.8;47.3;151.0;1790;74;26
16.11.2019 13:48:29;31.9;48.2;156.0;1817;68;26
16.11.2019 13:48:30;57.5;47.5;165.0;1806;71;26
16.11.2019 13:48:30;62.0;47.4;165.0;1784;73;26
16.11.2019 13:48:31;42.7;47.8;183.0;1789;71;27
16.11.2019 13:48:31;35.6;48.0;189.0;1856;70;27
16.11.2019 13:48:32;32.4;48.0;193.0;1833;70;28
16.11.2019 13:48:32;5.7;48.8;196.0;1983;58;28
16.11.2019 13:48:33;58.4;47.5;199.0;1788;72;28
16.11.2019 13:48:33;11.6;48.5;207.0;1820;63;28
16.11.2019 13:48:34;30.3;48.1;215.0;1803;64;28
16.11.2019 13:48:34;75.9;47.1;218.0;1765;73;28
16.11.2019 13:48:35;59.0;47.4;224.0;1767;71;29
16.11.2019 13:48:35;66.2;47.2;239.0;1774;72;29
16.11.2019 13:48:36;10.7;48.6;232.0;1768;63;29
16.11.2019 13:48:36;58.6;47.4;236.0;1797;72;29
16.11.2019 13:48:37;15.3;48.5;241.0;1773;64;29
16.11.2019 13:48:37;11.7;48.6;243.0;1762;63;29
16.11.2019 13:48:38;16.1;48.5;244.0;1771;64;29
16.11.2019 13:48:38;35.8;48.0;251.0;1768;66;29
16.11.2019 13:48:39;27.3;48.1;251.0;1779;64;29
16.11.2019 13:48:39;16.2;48.3;262.0;1781;68;30
16.11.2019 13:48:40;87.4;46.7;269.0;1759;75;30
16.11.2019 13:48:40;45.1;47.5;279.0;1793;72;30
16.11.2019 13:48:41;100.3;46.4;290.0;1756;76;30
16.11.2019 13:48:41;8.4;48.3;298.0;1833;62;31
16.11.2019 13:48:42;58.2;47.1;305.0;1803;73;31
16.11.2019 13:48:42;48.5;47.2;314.0;1773;72;31
16.11.2019 13:48:43;98.5;46.2;323.0;1818;76;31
16.11.2019 13:48:43;62.0;46.9;330.0;1770;70;32
16.11.2019 13:48:44;88.8;46.3;340.0;1775;74;32
16.11.2019 13:48:44;81.8;46.4;347.0;1759;74;32
16.11.2019 13:48:45;28.0;47.9;352.0;1689;5;32
16.11.2019 13:48:45;6.4;48.2;353.0;1308;51;33
16.11.2019 13:48:46;7.8;48.2;355.0;1155;44;33
16.11.2019 13:48:46;7.3;48.7;359.0;453;16;33
16.11.2019 13:50:22;0.4;49.2;374.0;0;0;25
16.11.2019 13:50:23;0.3;49.2;374.0;13;1;25
16.11.2019 13:50:23;1.9;49.2;374.0;19;5;25
16.11.2019 13:50:24;2.8;49.2;374.0;21;0;25
16.11.2019 13:50:24;10.6;49.0;375.0;38;8;25
16.11.2019 13:50:25;75.0;48.5;381.0;0;0;25
16.11.2019 13:50:34;0.4;49.2;382.0;18;0;26
RV 18 November 2019 00:0018.11.2019 00:00
Jo - da kann ich erstmal auch net viel dazu sagen.

Wie war denn genau die Situation? - Denn der Setpoint Noise war ja ca. 20s vor dem Einschlag.

Bitte berichte mal genau.

regards (EN) / Gruss (DE)

Rainer Vetter

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Posting and answering - please use a PC and a standard keyboard. Answer all questions fully, take the needed time, don't forget probably requested attachments.

Für Posts und Antworten bitte einen PC und eine richtige Taststaur benutzen sowie alle Fragen vollständig abarbeiten. Nehmt Euch Zeit, beantwortet Rückfragen in Ruhe und vollständig.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Für Einzelkommunikation bitte ausschließlich Email verwenden! - PN, Messenger, Chat usw. werden nicht bearbeitet.
For single user communication please send a email only! PM, Messenger, Chat etc. won't be read.
Kurvenkratzer 18 November 2019 08:5818.11.2019 08:58
I'll try to reconstruct it.

While I was flying, the VBar started making noises, then I did a few tic-tocs and then the power was gone. And then the helicopter came down.

Yes, apart from the fact that the damage is already done, I don't want this to happen again.

What can I do to prevent this from happening again?
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 18 November 2019 09:0418.11.2019 09:04
Looking back, I suspect the sounds were meant to represent the error message (of course I don't know for sure).

All plugs etc. were connected - I checked.
The controller also started working again without any problems - I checked that too.
I disconnected the speed sensor and the engine continued to run.
I don't know of any mechanical or electrical fault that could have caused it.

I've never encountered this issue before, and I've been flying in several helicopters with Stabi gov for 4 years.


And I've never seen such a beep and error message before.
machine-translated from German · Show original
RV 18 November 2019 20:4818.11.2019 20:48
Das waren die Töne:
16.11.2019 13:48:26 Info;YGE Setpoint Noise

Da war m.M. nach der Strom weg:
16.11.2019 13:48:45;28.0;47.9;352.0;1689;5;32

Also 20s später.

Ich denke Du solltest ggf. mal YGE fragen was die Meldung zu bedeuten hat.

regards (EN) / Gruss (DE)

Rainer Vetter

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Posting and answering - please use a PC and a standard keyboard. Answer all questions fully, take the needed time, don't forget probably requested attachments.

Für Posts und Antworten bitte einen PC und eine richtige Taststaur benutzen sowie alle Fragen vollständig abarbeiten. Nehmt Euch Zeit, beantwortet Rückfragen in Ruhe und vollständig.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Für Einzelkommunikation bitte ausschließlich Email verwenden! - PN, Messenger, Chat usw. werden nicht bearbeitet.
For single user communication please send a email only! PM, Messenger, Chat etc. won't be read.
RV 18 November 2019 22:2818.11.2019 22:28
Also ... der Setpoint Noise bedeutet ein gestörtes Gassignal am Eingang des Reglers.

Hast Du denn einen Verkabelungsplan des Ganzen?
Insbesondere wie sind die BEC's verhäkelt?
Warum wurde das KETO statt oder mit YGE verwendet?

regards (EN) / Gruss (DE)

Rainer Vetter

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Posting and answering - please use a PC and a standard keyboard. Answer all questions fully, take the needed time, don't forget probably requested attachments.

Für Posts und Antworten bitte einen PC und eine richtige Taststaur benutzen sowie alle Fragen vollständig abarbeiten. Nehmt Euch Zeit, beantwortet Rückfragen in Ruhe und vollständig.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Für Einzelkommunikation bitte ausschließlich Email verwenden! - PN, Messenger, Chat usw. werden nicht bearbeitet.
For single user communication please send a email only! PM, Messenger, Chat etc. won't be read.
Kurvenkratzer 19 November 2019 06:2619.11.2019 06:26
The 205 HVT does not have its own bec.
Hence the keto
I'll upload a schematic drawing here.



Edited once. Last edited on 19/11/2019 at 15:49 by Kurvenkratzer.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 19 November 2019 20:0619.11.2019 20:06
I've tried to draw the connection diagram here; I hope I haven't forgotten anything. The cable dimensions are approximate.

Since I am traveling for work, I cannot give you an exact figure.

machine-translated from German · Show original
JMalberg 21 November 2019 22:4821.11.2019 22:48
At what voltage does the Keto run?
How does the SBEC voltage behave in the Keto?
How is the signal line from the YGE to the Vstabi routed?

Regards, Jürgen
(Here are the missing commas for free use in my posts: ,,,,,,,,, )
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 22 November 2019 06:4322.11.2019 06:43
The Keto motor runs at 7.4V; I haven't monitored the voltage closely yet, as it's only been used for one flight. The cables were routed under the chassis to the rear and then upwards to the stabilizer. Completely standard...
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 23 November 2019 14:0223.11.2019 14:02
I've measured again... the cable from the BEC was
Soldered to + and - approximately 8 cm away from the regulator.

And the bec + - cable itself is approximately 18cm long from the soldering point to the Bec.
machine-translated from German · Show original
JMalberg 23 November 2019 16:2123.11.2019 16:21
My experience is that the Keto is somewhat "unsteady" at high voltages and doesn't hold the voltage as well as at lower voltages. Since then, I've been running it at 6V. But I can't say that this causes "YGE set point noise" or motor stalling.

The signal line might be affected if it runs directly alongside pulsating currents like the motor wires... possibly, maybe, could be. :-)

Regards, Jürgen
(Here are the missing commas for free use in my posts: ,,,,,,,,, )



Edited once. Last edited on 23/11/2019 at 16:23 by JMalberg.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 23 November 2019 19:4223.11.2019 19:42
I had already used Ketos in other helicopters but never had any problems.

The signal line from the YGE is actually only located next to the voltage line from the Keto and runs alongside it up to the stabilizer.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Kurvenkratzer 18 December 2019 08:4218.12.2019 08:42
So, after a great deal of patience and quite a bit of time on the phone
Have I now "bought" a YGE 205 HVT with BEC?

I sent in the VBar and it has been checked so far.
The error definitely did not come from the stabilizer but was caused by the controller (in conjunction with the Keto bec).
However, Mr. Jung was less than accommodating, considering he himself had said that this could be the cause!
Despite repeated requests to include a section in his instructions stating that failures could occur when using an external BEC other than the r² prototyping BEC, he simply refused.

What's the point of a controller without a BEC if you shouldn't install any other BEC besides a €150 one because there's a possibility the controller might fail?

I had to pay an additional 100 euros, which I had negotiated down from 150 euros.
...to get the one with bec in exchange.

Leaving aside the additional damage of approximately 600 euros that I incurred...

Many thanks again to Mikado, great work!

Eddie E. Please correct me and the other readers if I know what the problem might have been (in the interaction between the controller and the external BEC).

A little more understanding and goodwill from Yge would have been desirable here. Oh well.
For me, the quick takeaway is no more external BECs and no more YGE ESCs, solely because of the goodwill issue...
machine-translated from German · Show original
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless