Mark Norris
2 December 2025 06:1302.12.2025 06:13
Hello,
I have a vbar Evo and Xpert cyclic servos that can run up to 1000hz with a 760us pulse. Currently I'm using 1520us with 333Hz and only the tails is operationg at 760us.
Question, when going from 1520 to 760 doesnt the servo movement get reduced? How to get it back.
Example Min Center Max
1520us is approx 1000us - 1500us - 2000us
760us is approx 510us - 760us - 1010us.
Not sure if these numbers are accurate but I believe the centering will change and the movement will be reduced, can you help clarify please.
Mark
RV
2 December 2025 06:3002.12.2025 06:30
The goal for the 760us rate is to have more pulses in the same time. So the min/max. pulse length must be reduced (half) too - otherwise there were no pulses anymore at full deflection.
So - at the end - the min/max pulses will be "translated" by the servo into the same deflection even if they are only the half of the previous ones.
regards (EN) / Gruss (DE)
Rainer Vetter
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Posting and answering - please use a PC and a standard keyboard. Answer all questions fully, take the needed time, don't forget probably requested attachments.
Für Posts und Antworten bitte einen PC und eine richtige Taststaur benutzen sowie alle Fragen vollständig abarbeiten. Nehmt Euch Zeit, beantwortet Rückfragen in Ruhe und vollständig.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Für Einzelkommunikation bitte ausschließlich Email verwenden! - PN, Messenger, Chat usw. werden nicht bearbeitet.
For single user communication please send a email only! PM, Messenger, Chat etc. won't be read.
Mark Norris
2 December 2025 06:5102.12.2025 06:51
Thanks Rainer,
Honesty corner here - Just playing around I changed the pulse width of the cyclic servos from 1520 333 to 760 333 and immidiatley the servos moved and one servo arm broke because of the way off centering. After I removed servo arms just playing around I noticed that not only was the centering way off but the movement was approx half.
I'm using a new EVO and 3 Xpert HS-6403-HV KD2 cyclic servos that say in the spec they can autodetect 1520 vs 760us and also that they can go up to 1000Hz.
Should they not have jumped when I changed the setting.
Mark
Eddi E. aus G.
2 December 2025 09:1902.12.2025 09:19
Hi Mark,
when changing the settings, you should disconnect the servo links or remove the servo arms, if there are mechanical limits.
Technically, when booted up with the correct settings (or correct auto detect), the servo travel should be the same no matter if wide pulse or narrow pulse.
When switching, or if auto detect fails somehow, you will see an offset and reduced (or increased) travel.
Same as if you select the wrong tail servo type for your actual servo.
Auto detect usually requires a restart, or dis-/connecting the servo.
Auto detect usually happens only once at power up, not continuously during operation, else it could react to interference and mess things up even worse.
The refresh rate is a different animal, it says how many inputs per second the servo electronics can safely handle.
Everything below spec can be considered be safe, everything above spec can lead to the servo becoming hot, quickly.
But the refresh rate does nothing with the center or limits (unless it was so high that the servo electronics couldn't resolve the signal any more, then the servo would either not do anything (if properly programmed, no valid input, standby), or go crazy (if the developer/programmer didn't foresee this particular possible user error).
Best,
Eddi
Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 12/02/2025 09:19AM by Eddi E. aus G..
Mark Norris
2 December 2025 15:4002.12.2025 15:40
Hello,
Tryng to understand (I think I do). On an auto detect servo during powerup the servo sees what pulse width the TX is commanding at wherever the stick positions happen to be. Is it true that the lower range and the higher range can never overlap so there will hopeully never be confusion.
With my numbers below the Narrrow_High and Standard_Low get pretty clos but I do not know if the spreads are correct.
I used Narrow 760us center +/-250 width & 1520us center +/- 500 width. Can you confirm the actual numbers so I can better understand.
Approx us
Narrow_Low 510
Narrow_Center 760
Narrow_High 1010
Standard_Low 1020
Standard_Center 1520
Standard_High 2020
I will try a power cycle next time I want to get brave enough to tinker with 760, not sure I will but just want to fully understand.
Thanks
Mark Norris
Eddi E. aus G.
2 December 2025 16:1302.12.2025 16:13
Hi Mark,
the usual range is rather +/– 200 µs for the narrow pulse and +/– 400 µs for the wide pulse, plus margin for trims and such.
So it's rather 560-760-960 and 1120-1520-1920 (plus margins/trims).
But there is no actual standard, everyone does like he feels like, or so it seems.
The ranges don't overlap.
Still, almost every servo does 'something' when driven with a wrong center pulse or an ambiguous/unexpected pulse width.
Quote:Anecdote
One example from way back, some JR servos just went limp when their max. pulse range was exceeded (cyclic plus collective plus trim offsets added up), causing funny jolts or what felt like brief partial losses of control in the air, when doing 3D. I still remember the 'there's something wrong with the VBar' complaints, where it was reproducible even on the ground that if you trimmed only the necessary maximum (low two-digit range max, with good mechanical setup), and went to sensible throws for cycling and collective (80-100 range, with good rotor head geometry), all was well. When you upped the values electronically, the servo pulse went wider (obviously) and at some point the servo went like 'nah, can't be, I'm out ...' until the pulse was back within the margins again.
Rule number one: when something's off or wrong, it's always the VBar ;-)
Rule number two: not so often as you might actually think ;-)
If you set the servo to the proper pulse, and the VBar accordingly, all is well.
Same as with tail servos, which for quite some time had a fixed pulse, you'd had to chose when you purchased, and you had to select the corresponding setting (center pulse/pulse width) in Setup.
If auto detect, let the thing do it at least once ;-) and mind that changing the setting in the VBar will change the output instantly, so better disconnect the servos at that time, or unlink the swash plate/check that nuts below the servo arms also can not bind with the servo housing or anything.
Best,
Eddi
Born to fly ...
forced to work.