← Logo 700 and 800

Tail Gearbox Gears

Mikado Model Helicopters › Logo 700 and 800 · Started by wizza on 16 September 2016 00:2416.09.2016 00:24
wizza 16 September 2016 00:2416.09.2016 00:24
Hi Guys,

The build on the tail gear has me concerned, so thought I'd stop and ask some opinion. If you look at the rear umbrella gear off the torque tube, there is nothing in the molding to set or seat the bearing (position) closest to the gear. If you push the bearing all the way on, the gear actually rubs on the back of the housing, and the gear mesh is very loose. If you pull the bearing back out a touch, you can get the mesh better, but nothing to hold it there. Are you supposed to glue it in position, like the old Align torque tube bearings..??? How then to you set the gear mesh / back-lash..??? Not sure what the design/plan was here, but its concerning me a little. Any thoughts out there, or has anyone already done something to address this possible issue..??

MarkR
wizza 16 September 2016 03:2516.09.2016 03:25
If you have a look at the design, even after full assembly with the boom and torque tube inserted, there is nothing to stop the umbrella gear moving forward or back, on the end of the torque tube, thereby altering the gear mesh / back lash... Other than friction of the bearing fit on the umbrella gear, and mine isn't that tight a fit. Should we use a little CA on a tooth-pick, and glue the bearings in place..??? Or look for a 15x17 shim washer between the back of the umbrella gear and the first bearing..????



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 09/16/2016 03:25AM by wizza.
Eddi E. aus G. 16 September 2016 08:4716.09.2016 08:47
Hi,

by default, the gear in line with the torque tube sits on the inner bearing in the tail rotor housing, and the gear in line with the tail shaft on the bearing on the left (direction of flight). They won't go anywhere else even if there is a little axial play, under load gears always want to move away from each other, as a reaction to the power they have to transfer.

This results in the intended gear mesh/back lash, not too loose, not too tight, which has been tried and tested for 1.000s of flights without issues, without the need to change it.

On the 700 XX it was the same, by the way, and the same fixes may apply if required: you can always shim the tail shaft gear a little to move it slightly closer to the torque tube gear. On the 700 XX this was necessary at times, the open gear collected more abrasive foreign parts and the design probably allowed for a quicker wear when flying XXtremely hard (on mine, 2.5 D and big air, no need to change anything for one and a half seasons and hundreds of flights).

Obviously the gears should not rub anywhere, just sit tight against the bearings. If this is not the case, please check for excess plastic at the teeth and the back side of the gears, maybe it just did not come out clean enough out of the mold.

Of course, you can also shim the torque tube gear, just make sure the shim can not block the gear. I'm pretty sure that glueing would not hold for long, and if, if you ever had to change anything (exchange the bearing or the gear), it would mean to exchange both.

I will see what more I can find out, and be back.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 09/16/2016 02:23PM by Eddi E. aus G..
Eddi E. aus G. 16 September 2016 09:2816.09.2016 09:28
Hi again,

OK, here we go: there should be a kind of a notch where the gear sits at the inner bearing ring.
In fact, the shaft of the gear is milled perfectly round after molding, so it would be possible that this notch has been milled off by accident and that it went unnoticed.

You can do a cross check: the gear is the same part as in the chassis, so if you compare gears or exchange gears, you should know.
Imo it's quite unlikely that you got yourself two bad parts.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.

wizza 16 September 2016 13:3616.09.2016 13:36
Eddi, your a champion...!!! That may explain what's going on. I don't think my gear has a flange behind the gear, like pictured above. I'll check it tomorrow, and compare it to the chassis gear (didn't know they were the same - haven't got that far into the build). Thanks Eddi.

Mark R



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 09/16/2016 01:43PM by wizza.
3D Dave 17 September 2016 06:3217.09.2016 06:32
Mark and Eddi, I have a question also pertaining to this gear so thought I'd post it here...

Ok, I it might be a dumb question but I'd rather ask to be 100% sure before I cut the tiny plastic tabs.

Looking in the top of both the front and rear umbrella gears (that go on the ends of the torque tube), there are 2 little plastic protrusions opposite each other that prevent the metal ends (#5037) that go on each end from going all the way through.

Can you confirm that they are just flashing from the mold and can be cut off?

It looks like the expanded metal tip might actually supposed to snap lock right through the end of the bevel gears but if I leave the tabs on, the metal torque tube tip will not go all the way through.

Thanks.
wizza 18 September 2016 08:2318.09.2016 08:23
Hi Eddi, You were spot on... I have a faulty bevel gear. The machined notch at the rear of the gear, that is supposed to step the bearing out is just about non-existent. I have attached a photo of the gear. I measured what notch is there, with the calipers, and its only about 0.12mm.

Could you please measure a "good" gear, and tell me how many mm's the step/notch should be..?? I want to check the other gear to ensure it is ok...

Many thanks...

wizza 19 September 2016 03:2619.09.2016 03:26
Eddi, what measurement should the step be...? I want to measure the other one, but have no reference...

Mark R
Eddi E. aus G. 19 September 2016 09:0519.09.2016 09:05
Hi,

I measure 8-9/10s of a mm. Not much in fact.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
wizza 19 September 2016 14:0219.09.2016 14:02
Thanks Eddi. I also measured about 0.9mm on the good gear that I have, so that confirms for me. I assembled the tail gearbox tonight with that good gear, and the mesh was nice and smooth. All I needed was about 0.3mm of shim on the tail shaft to take out the lateral play, which was effecting the mesh. All good now...

Thanks Eddi...
Eddi E. aus G. 19 September 2016 14:3019.09.2016 14:30
:-)

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless