← Logo 700 and 800

Component selection + questions translated

Mikado Model Helicopters › Logo 700 and 800 · Started by delta peak on 13 September 2016 17:4313.09.2016 17:43
delta peak 13 September 2016 17:4313.09.2016 17:43
Well, I've been eyeing the 700 for quite some time now, and now it's finally time to take a look at the components :-)

My flying style is a mix of relaxed and hard flying, but for Smacken, the components should definitely be of sufficient size.
However, I don't want it to be too heavy either.

Here's my introduction:

Scorpion HK 4525-520
Yge 160HV with/without heatsink?
Savox SB-2272MG
Savox SB-2271SG
Unisens 280
Ac3x V3
4500 mAh battery

A receiver battery is now required due to the controller.
I'm still not entirely sure which size.
The question is, how long can you fly with it?
As far as I could see, Mirko's helicopter has a 1300mAh 2S battery installed, strapped to the main battery.
I'm guessing it recharges after every flight. Can you tell me anything about that? Does it use a lot of power?
The advantages are: cheap, if the main battery fails, there is still power to the servos, simple and, well, lightweight, at least the same weight as an HV2BEC.
An HV-BEC would have the advantage of constant voltage; you only need to charge one battery. However, if the main battery fails, tough luck. Unless you add an R2 buffer, but that adds weight and cables.

I'm leaning more towards the battery option. How should it be connected? I was thinking of using MPX connectors, where I could solder a small circuit board onto the receiver-side connector (for better grip) and then solder two servo connectors onto it. I think that would be quite simple.

What suggestions would you have?

Regards, Daniel
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 14 September 2016 08:3714.09.2016 08:37
Hi,

Kühlkörper oder nicht, schwer zu sagen. Beim 700-er (schon beim XX) nicht zwingend nötig.

Akku ist sicher nicht schlecht, man wird so 300-500 mAh / Flug verbrauchen für die Anlage, also nachdem man's ermittelt hat (fliegen, laden, was geht rein) 1-2 Flüge mit Reserve beim 1.300 mAh, die gewünschte Kapazität des Empfänger-Akkus kann man dann ja frei wählen.

Anschluss, EC3 ... verpolungssicher und solide, und braucht keine Hilfskonstruktionen.

Ich persönlich würde eher ein BEC verwenden, noch lieber einen Regler mit BEC (da wird die Luft dünn oder teuer), ich möchte mich eigentlich nur um den Flug-Akku kümmern. Klar kann man für alles zum Knopf noch Gürtel und Hosenträger einbauen, aber wenn was passiert wird es dort passieren, wo man keine Redundanz eingebaut hat ... Murphy kennt die ganzen Tricks auch ;-) ... der Empfänger-Akku ist genauso sicher wie der Haupt-Akku, wenn man's genau nimmt, also bräuchte man dort auch einen Puffer. Der Haupt-Akku hat den Vorteil, dass er auch leergelutscht noch genug Saft für die RC-Anlage liefert.

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
delta peak 14 September 2016 15:1714.09.2016 15:17
Thanks Eddi!

EC3 plug sounds better :-)

I did some calculations and came up with the following selection:

YGE 160 with heatsink (Can't hurt, really)
R2 Buffer 25f (Is an R-board required for HV²BEC ALU?)
HV²BEC ALU

It's not the cheapest option, but for that price you'd only get the Kosmik.
This makes it easier and less maintenance-intensive, and since I won't be making a quick decision, I still have plenty of time to think it over :-)

Regards, Daniel



Edited once. Last edited on 14.09.2016 at 15:19 by delta peak.
machine-translated from German · Show original
MH 14 September 2016 15:2714.09.2016 15:27
I'll throw the Hobbywing Platinum Pro 160A HV 5 into the mix. It's currently available for a relatively low price, and you save yourself the cost of an HV BEC.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 14 September 2016 15:5814.09.2016 15:58
Hi,

mit den R2Prototyping-Produkten habe ich keine Ahnung, ob man zu dem noch das benötigt.

HW ist sicher auch eine Option, ich wäre neugierig, was das BEC wirklich kann.

Der Scorpion Tribunus soll auch ein gutes BEC haben, G v Gansen (Chef von Scorpion) hat zwar auch noch ein Backup Guard drin, aber er meint, auch nur um sich mit minimalem Mehrgewicht noch eine zusätzliche Sicherheit zu holen ... bei der Speed-Fliegerei wie er sie betreibt sollen sich auch schon Stecker abgelötet haben :-)

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
delta peak 14 September 2016 16:5514.09.2016 16:55
Hardware would also be an option, but it's mostly Chinese stuff (although I haven't read anything negative about it).

It's a bit more expensive (the 160mm version at Schweigh... €440 instead of €600) than the YGE. They've apparently sold well; they're currently out of stock.
Maybe I'll take a look at the hardware. What do you think, Eddi? Should I play the tester? :-)

Regards, Daniel
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 14 September 2016 17:1114.09.2016 17:11
Mach ruhig :-)

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
delta peak 14 September 2016 17:2414.09.2016 17:24
Quote: Go ahead and use a grinning smiley
Without even flinching, eh? :-)

Ahhh! In stock at WOH - €500. Not exactly cheap, but you save on the HV BEC. The Ac3x also conveniently allows you to log the receiver voltage.
I think I'll download the manual from HW :-)

Regards, Daniel
machine-translated from German · Show original
MH 14 September 2016 17:4314.09.2016 17:43
Just Google "HW". I immediately found two alternatives that have it in stock for €435...
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 14 September 2016 17:4914.09.2016 17:49
Hi,

naja, die HW haben inzwischen einen guten Ruf, zumindest liest man keine Horror-Meldungen, im Internet funktioniert ja meist nur der Umkehrschluss.

BEC, kP. Versuch macht kluch. Oder messen mit Oszi. Telemetrie ist i. d. R. zu langsam, ist wie 'ne Dia-Show gegenüber einem Film. Nur wenn direkt am Prozessor gemessen wird kommt das schnell, aber dann ist's i. d. R. zu spät und reicht nur noch für eine Nachbetrachtung :-)

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Wolfram 14 September 2016 21:3014.09.2016 21:30
Hello,

What also makes the Hobbywing controllers interesting is the fact that there is now a firmware for the HW-V4 version of JLog.

The controls can also be adjusted very conveniently and clearly using the LCD interface.

Regards, Wolfram
machine-translated from German · Show original
Wolfram 14 September 2016 21:3614.09.2016 21:36
Hi Daniel,

You don't need an R board for the HV²-BEC.

They are needed for the K-Power-Jive and the K-Heli-Jive because, in the event of a drive battery failure, these controllers continue to commutate the motor from the buffer capacitor for a few seconds.

I don't know if this is also the case with the JIVE-Pro.
But you can certainly ask Kontronik.

Regards, Wolfram
machine-translated from German · Show original
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless